The Master Teacher Blog

The Master Teacher Blog
Providing you, the K-12 leader, with the help you need to lead with clarity, credibility, and confidence in the ever-evolving world of education.
Browse Topics
Seven Habits of Highly Magnetic Teachers

Seven Habits of Highly Magnetic Teachers

Some teachers seem like natural “magnets” for students. Students want to be in their classes, hang around their classrooms, and join clubs and participate in activities that these teachers supervise. These teachers can have an outsized influence on the learning, behavior, and even life aspirations of the students in their orbit. 

We might think that the magnetism these teachers project is a natural gift that is not available to everyone. Yet, magnetism is not simply a talent or personality trait; in fact, almost anyone can learn to project this kind of appeal. It is made up of learnable skills and applied behaviors that make students want to listen, connect, and participate.
 
Interestingly, being able to draw students in starts with us being ourselves, showing interest in students, and responding to their need to belong. Here are seven behaviors and practices that, when combined, can create a magnetic force in our relationships with students: 

Presence. Teachers who communicate presence make students feel as though they are giving their full attention to what they are teaching and what is happening. They give their undivided attention as they interact with students. They resist distractions, listen carefully, and avoid interrupting. Presence sends the message, “What I am doing now is what is most important at this moment.” It makes students feel seen and respected. 

Practicing presence: Let go of distractions, pause unrelated tasks, and give your full attention. 

Confidence. Teachers having confidence does not mean that they need to know everything. However, students do want to feel that their teachers know and care about what they say and do. Students want to feel that we value what we teach and understand its purpose. Our words and actions need to communicate that what we are asking students to learn matters. If we want students to believe that what they are learning has value, they need to feel it from us first.

Communicating confidence: Come fully prepared. Share interesting tidbits and insights to stimulate students’ interest and curiosity. Discuss how students might use what they are learning. 

Clarity. Students want assurance that their teachers know where their learning is leading. We can build and share learning paths and goals to reduce any confusion and uncertainty. Giving students specific, consistent expectations reassures them and builds their confidence in their ability to succeed. Staying attuned to when students need more detail or smaller chunks of information also helps them gain clarity. 

Conveying clarity: Introduce learning activities by explaining what students will learn and how they can succeed with their tasks and assignments.  

Authenticity. Students are attracted to teachers they believe are genuine and not pretending to be someone they are not. In fact, students can be drawn to teachers who may be a little quirky, have a unique sense of humor, or see life a little differently. We are most authentic when we play to our strengths rather than focusing on masking what we see as our weaknesses.  

Articulating authenticity: Share who you are, what you love about what you do, and how learning with you can be a unique and rich experience. 

Energy. Teachers’ energy can be contagious and can fuel students’ energy. It does not have to be constant or excessive, but it does need to be genuine. We can effectively share our energy and excitement through our facial expressions, tone of voice, speaking pace, and body movements. In addition, our intellectual excitement, curiosity, and surprise can draw students in and invite them to share the experience. 

Expressing energy: Constant high energy can be exhausting for both students and you. Vary your volume, pace, movements, and gestures to elevate and lower energy throughout teaching and learning cycles, thus creating sustained engagement and offering opportunities for recovery and reflection.

Warmth. Warmth does not always mean being soft and cuddly. In fact, it can take multiple forms. In any form, warmth makes students feel seen, accepted, and understood. Warmth can be found in our interest in students, our support for their learning success, and our concern for their personal well-being.  

Sharing warmth: We can assure students that we see them, are interested in their lives and interests, want them to succeed, and care about them. 

Curiosity. Curiosity is a component of several of the other characteristics on this list. Being curious is not evidence that we do not know what we should; rather, it is evidence that we remain interested, are fascinated by what we do not know, and are ready to explore. Our curiosity can create an environment in which we share the excitement of intellectual mysteries and possibilities with students.

Curating curiosity: Admit that you may not be sure or have not encountered a question or possibility, especially when the inquiry comes from students. An invitation to explore and discover together can be irresistible. 

Of course, not every behavior or practice must be fully or constantly present in our interactions with students. However, the more students experience these elements, the stronger the pull they will feel and the greater the influence we can have in their learning and lives. 

The Student Engagement Trap

The Student Engagement Trap

We might think that learning is easy to observe. We can see whether students seem to be paying attention, whether they are participating in discussions and activities, and whether they appear to be enjoying the experience. Yet, none of these behaviors necessarily constitute evidence that learning is happening. 

It is true that if none of these behaviors are present, students are probably not learning or are not learning much. Learning requires attention, is facilitated by participation, and may be enhanced when students enjoy the experience. However, just because students are engaged does not mean they are gaining the intended learning.

A new report from the American Psychological Association makes this point about students’ engagement and learning while using educational technology. The authors note that students being engaged with technology does not mean that they are gaining the intended learning. However, this insight is not new, nor is it confined to using technology. In fact, educators have long struggled to ensure that the activities they plan and present to students will result in learning, not just engagement. Decades ago, noted UCLA professor Madeline Hunter labeled engagement without learning as “activating.” Students may attend, participate, and even enjoy activities that fail to produce the intended learning.
 
When we consider the role of engagement in learning, we might think about three types: behavioral, emotional, and cognitive. When students behave in ways that demonstrate engagement—busy, compliant, participating—learning might be happening. When students are emotionally engaged—interested, excited, enjoying—learning could be happening. However, when students are cognitively engaged—reasoning, explaining, retrieving, applying—we can be sure that learning is happening. 

So, how can we be certain the activities we design are leading to learning? Here are seven indicators to monitor and evidence to watch for:

  • Students understand the activity’s purpose. Unless students know what they are supposed to learn, they risk missing the target. Students can be highly engaged and learn how to do an activity but still miss what we intended them to learn.  
  • Students are thinking, not just doing. We can monitor whether students can explain what they are doing, justify their choices, and use related information to solve problems, not just follow directions.
  • Students retrieve and connect past learning. Learning grows and sticks when students can see how what they are learning relates to and builds on what they have learned in the past.
  • Students find the learning challenging. When students experience learning activities that are easy, it often means they already know what they are being asked to learn. When students pause to think, wrestle with problems, and learn from mistakes, learning is more likely to happen and stay.
  • Students receive feedback and act on it. When students continue to engage without feedback, they are likely to repeat mistakes, fail to progress, or give up and disengage. When students receive feedback, revise their performance accordingly, and move forward, learning is more likely to occur and last.
  • Students can transfer their learning to other contexts. When students use information from a learning activity to solve a new problem, apply it in a related situation, or explain its value beyond the initial activity, we can be certain learning has occurred.
  • Students retain new learning after the activity concludes. When students can retrieve, apply, and build on what they learned days, weeks, or even months after the activity, we can be confident that what they experienced was more than a memorable moment.

Whether we present learning-related games, design a class activity, or have students engage in educational technology, we need to be mindful of what will generate the intended learning and what might be a distraction that generates engagement and little more.  

 

Reference: 
Barnes, N., Mallick, D. B., Evans, C. L., Hirsh-Pasek, K., Irshad, G., Lane, H. C., Mayer, R. E., Means, B., Golinkoff, R. M., Nunes, L., Pardos, Z. A., Radesky, J., Vanacore, K., & Willingham, D. T. (2026, September). Children’s and adolescent’ learning with educational technology. American Psychological Association. https://www.apa.org/pubs/reports/children-adolescent-learning-educational-technology 

The Classroom Productivity Strategy Too Few Teachers Use

The Classroom Productivity Strategy Too Few Teachers Use

The idea of having students assume significant and meaningful roles in our classroom may seem like more work and headaches. Yet, if tasks and responsibilities are planned and managed well, students’ contributions can lighten our workload and create more time for us to plan and teach.  

However, the case for having students assume meaningful classroom-level responsibilities and carry out authentic tasks is most compelling when viewed from the perspective of their benefits for students. These experiences can be powerful opportunities for students to develop agency, leadership, competence, and a sense of ownership and belonging. Students go beyond being occupants of our classroom to contributors to its success.  

So, what are some of the tasks and responsibilities students might carry out that lighten our load and build student confidence and skills? Here are some examples, depending on the ages and maturity of the students we teach.  

Students can: 

  • Manage and distribute materials 

  • Lead classroom routines  

  • Teach classmates 

  • Design review activities for classmates 

  • Facilitate group work 

  • Lead discussions 

  • Manage technology 

Of course, you can add to this list as you consider your context and students. Nevertheless, students almost always can do more than we assume. They may just need an opportunity, reasonable support, and recognition that their efforts matter.  

Meanwhile, the growth in skills, maturity, attitudes, and commitment that results from these authentic opportunities is likely to be significant. Consider these examples of how students benefit from playing a meaningful role in and carrying out classroom responsibilities.  

Students grow in their sense of agency. They connect their actions to meaningful outcomes. Consequently, they see themselves as making the class better. They are positively influencing the classroom environment, not just reacting to it.  

Students gain confidence and competence. They begin to see themselves as someone who can be depended upon. They feel capable of carrying out responsibilities and solving problems. The confidence that comes from performing and making contributions tends to be more meaningful and durable than confidence that is dependent on praise.  

Students learn to lead. When students engage in tasks such as organizing peer groups, leading discussions, teaching classmates, and helping to manage classroom routines, they begin to see themselves as able to support, manage, and influence others. Depending on students to carry out responsibilities communicates confidence in their abilities, including leadership.  

Students become more invested in the classroom community. When students contribute to how the classroom functions, they tend to take greater ownership of elements such as routines, norms, and collective success. Students are more likely to internalize classroom expectations and see them as shared commitments to pursue rather than as the teacher’s rules. 

Students grow executive functioning skills. When students are given responsibilities that involve planning, prioritizing, monitoring progress, and managing materials, they learn important life and work skills that can serve them well academically and in life. In fact, executive work skills are among the strongest predictors of long-term academic and work success.  

If having students play significant roles and taking on responsibilities in your classroom is not something to which you are accustomed, you will need to start slowly and build as your students and you are ready. There will be missteps and setbacks along the way, but do not be discouraged. The growth of your students will be surprising, and the tasks you will no longer have to perform will offer welcome relief.

Six Questions That Make Learning Matter

Six Questions That Make Learning Matter

Helping students to see the purpose of academic learning is an age-old challenge. Students often see learning in school as something adults expect, with little relevance or utility in their lives. Of course, the structure of most formal curricula contributes to this challenge.  

Too often, courses confine their focus to information, processes, and skills that comprise an academic discipline rather than the broader context within which learning occurs. Unless we supplement, make connections, and invite students to connect and apply their learning beyond what is presented, they are likely to miss much of the value and potential of what they learn.  

When students fail to see connections and miss the relevance of what they are asked to learn, we can expect questions such as, “Why do we have to learn this?” and “When will we ever need to use this?” Fortunately, we can prevent many of these questions by intentionally engaging students in thinking challenges and connection-making that help them to see value in what they are learning, without us having to constantly explain and defend it. Here are six question prompts to get started with and build on.  

What could you do with what you have learned?  

When students apply what they have learned, they immediately begin to solidify their understanding and move new learning into long-term memory.  

Examples: 

  • Students might invent math word problems that demonstrate understanding and apply what they have learned.  

  • They might write a letter or other communication using newly learned persuasive techniques to convince an authentic audience about something they care about. 

  • They might plan a trip that highlights geographic, cultural, and historic highlights using background information and strategies they have learned in geography.  

Who could you help with what you have learned?  

When new learning is used to provide a service or benefit another person, it is solidified, gains value, and students feel better about themselves.  

Examples: 

  • Students might help a family member modify a favorite recipe using fractions and ratios.  

  • They might volunteer to read to an elderly person using newly learned techniques of expression, emotional cues, and varying voices.  

  • They might use emerging world language skills to engage in conversation with or advocate for someone whose first language is not English. 

Who could you teach what you just learned?  

Teaching others is a great way to establish relevance, strengthen new learning, uncover areas in need of strengthening, and build recall.  

Examples: 

  • Students might share what they learned about counting money and making change with a younger student or sibling.  

  • They might teach a sibling or neighbor the relationship between newly learned words and sounds.  

  • They could visit an art museum with their family or friends and point out techniques, colors, materials, and how they contribute to a painting or sculpture.  

  • They might propose a design for a space using constraints such as square footage, light location, and furnishings, using geometric principles.  

How could you use what you have learned outside of school?  

Transferring learning from one context to another can deepen understanding, strengthen memory, and integrate academic learning into practical applications. Helping students to see broader applications of what they learn can make academic learning more meaningful and build motivation.  

Examples:  

  • Students might use persuasive techniques to advocate for an issue they care about. 

  • They might use newly learned economic principles to plan a business start-up or build a personal financial plan.  

  • They might use their knowledge of physics to design a new type of skateboard park.  

How might you connect what you have learned with something you have learned in another class?  

Finding ways to integrate learning across subjects can be a powerful way to build knowledge while helping students to see learning not solely as confined to a specific course.  

Examples:  

  • Students might use what they have learned in music to turn a poem they wrote into an original song.  

  • They might employ what they have learned about statistics and probability to analyze and make predictions about the spread of disease or the impact of lifestyle on longevity.  

  • They might also use art and design techniques to communicate messages related to an issue they care about.     

How could you demonstrate your learning in a way that is better than a test?  

We know assessments that ask students to respond to specific questions are limited in what they tell us about the full extent of what students know and can do. Demonstrations, presentations, and exhibits can communicate a wider range of information about learning. Meanwhile, learning deepens when students show and explain what they have learned.  

Examples:  

  • Students might teach a mini lesson.  

  • They write a formal argument defending a position. 

  • They could develop a set of instructions or record a video to demonstrate a technique or process.  

Purpose and relevance are important components of learning. When students see relevance, they can make better connections and are more likely to feel motivated to learn. When learning serves a purpose, learning tends to be deeper and recalled longer. When we prompt students to think and act beyond what the curriculum presents, we make learning more inviting, useful, and memorable.  

What Students Get Wrong About Learning—And How to Fix It

What Students Get Wrong About Learning—And How to Fix It

Learning is plagued by a surprising array of misconceptions. Some have roots in myths and traditions. Others grow out of common sayings that fail to capture the true nature of learning. Still others are reinforced by practices and exhortations we adopt to create shortcuts and make learning challenges easier to manage.  

Of course, students come to us with many of these misconceptions embedded in their assumptions, beliefs, and behaviors. Yet, what students think about learning can drive how they engage and influence their aspirations, effort, and persistence. Let’s examine seven of the most common misconceptions about learning, how they can get in the way of student success, and how we can counter them in our work with students.  

Misconception #1: Learning is taking in information. Obviously, learning involves becoming aware of and understanding information. However, being able to repeat or recite information is, at best, a first step in the learning process. Learning happens as students organize, connect, apply, and use what they are learning to gain new insights and generate new ideas.   

Counter conception: Learning is not what enters the brain. Learning is what you do with information once in the brain to understand, apply, and create.  

Misconception #2: Intelligence is more important than effort. Clearly, intelligence plays a role in learning. However, “being smart” is of little value if it is not supported by discipline, persistence, and application. On the other hand, consistently applied effort, good strategies, and focus can lead to more learning success than intelligence alone. In fact, research shows that people who develop and practice good work and learning habits are more successful in life than people who rely on natural intelligence.  

Counter conception: Good learners choose good strategies and give consistent, focused effort regardless of their natural talent.  

Misconception #3: Fast learning is good learning. Adults often inadvertently reinforce this misconception. We sometimes describe students who find learning easy as being smart. In fact, students who find learning easy are often good at memorizing, but they may not be able to recall much of what they learn. The saying “easy come, easy go,” applies here. Meanwhile, when students must struggle to grasp a concept or develop a skill, they are more likely to retain what they have learned. The brain connects effort to importance. Putting in significant effort can make what is learned easier to recall.   

Counter conception: Having to focus, practice, and invest in learning can make it stick longer than learning that comes easily.  

Misconception #4: Practice makes perfect. In the words of legendary football coach Vince Lombardi, “Practice does not make perfect. Perfect practice makes perfect.” What is practiced becomes stronger and more deeply embedded in memory, including mistakes. Practice that improves performance includes attention to detail and technique, feedback, and successive adjustments.  

Counter conception: Deliberate, purposeful practice supported by feedback and adjustment supports progress toward perfection.   

Misconception #5: Forgetting is evidence of poor learning. Forgetting is a natural process the brain uses to let go of what it assumes is not important. If something is learned, but not practiced or used frequently, the brain lets it go in favor of what is used more often. If students want to remember something, they need to retrieve it or use it to keep it fresh. Interestingly, every time information and skills are retrieved, they embed themselves more deeply in memory and become easier to recall in the future.  

Counter conception: Forgetting is natural, but we remember what we revisit and refresh. The more we retrieve and use information, the longer we will retain it.  

Misconception #6: Tests signal the end of learning. This misconception makes sense when students see the purpose of learning as preparing for a test. When the test is finished, what was learned no longer seems to have a purpose. Consequently, they often quickly forget what they have learned. On the other hand, when students learn to gain knowledge, influence, capability, and life options, retaining what they learn remains a priority. We can help students remember what they have learned by engaging them in frequent review and retrieval practice, and by designing activities that require students to use prior learning to accomplish new tasks and understand new concepts.  

Counter conception: Assessments are measures of progress and mastery. However, the purpose and value of learning reside in what is retained and can be used long after the test is over. 

Misconception #7: If I cannot learn it today, I cannot learn it. Students often believe that if they try something and are not successful, it is evidence that they cannot be successful. Yet most complex, challenging skills are developed over time. Not achieving immediate success means more work is needed, not that success isn’t possible.  

Counter conception: By learning from mistakes, focusing on progress, and using feedback, what seems impossible today can be within reach tomorrow. “Not yet” does not mean “not possible.”  

Misconceptions about how learning happens and what makes learning remain accessible are common, but they are not inevitable. Taking time to help students dispel assumptions and adjust their beliefs about learning can reap rich rewards while students are with us and can help to prepare them for a life of learning success.

Simplify Your Teaching, Amplify Student Learning

Simplify Your Teaching, Amplify Student Learning

We have a lot to say and much to share with our students, especially at this time of the year. We want students to hear, understand, and absorb as much as possible during their time with us. We may fear that we will overlook something, not explain something, or not give students enough. Consequently, we may spend our days sharing, explaining, directing, and repeating so that students are exposed to everything they need.  

Yet, there is danger in saying too much, giving too much, and even repeating too much. In fact, we are likely to be more successful in our instruction, and students are likely to be more successful in their learning, when we say less, focus more, and create more space for students to think, share, and explore.  

We might borrow from the philosophical principle of parsimony, which focuses on what is essential and avoids making things more complicated or difficult than necessary. It is true that teaching requires nuance and features complexity, but teaching and other forms of communication are most effective when the focus is on achieving their purpose while employing the fewest words, ideas, assumptions, and distractions. 

So how might the principle of parsimony be applied in our work? Admittedly, what to cut, trim, and avoid can be challenging. We may have to shift some focus, avoid some habits, and adjust some practices, but the increases we see in learning and the reduction we experience in our stress and our workload will be more than worth the effort. Here are six examples to consider and build on.  

Say less and let students think, talk, and learn more. As teachers, we typically like to talk. That is why we chose a profession that is highly dependent on communication. However, our inclination to speak—especially excessively—can get in the way of students’ learning and independence. When we engage in excessive talking, students have less time to think and learn. We might ask ourselves whether what we are about to say is something students could discover on their own. Is it something we should position as a discussion rather than a statement? Or might students reflect and explain to each other? There is a saying that the person who is learning the most in a classroom is the person who is speaking the most and working the hardest. That person should not be us.  

Clear the conversational clog. We might believe that lengthy, detailed explanations lead to more understanding, but students are more likely to grasp and recall what we say if we are succinct. Similarly, limiting the number of instructions we give can reduce the cognitive load students experience and can lead to fewer misunderstandings and mistakes. Breaking procedures into manageable chunks, giving one instruction at a time, and checking to see that students are ready before moving to the next instruction can significantly reduce confusion, off-task behavior, and requests for clarification and repetition.  

Replace repetition with precision. When students do not understand or are confused by our instruction or explanation, we can be tempted to simply repeat what we said, often louder and with more emphasis. Yet, repeating what led to misunderstanding or confusion holds limited promise of improving the situation. Everyone’s interests are better served by our reflecting on what may have created the condition. We might ask ourselves if we were clear, whether we emphasized what is most important, or if we need to offer a better, more precise example. We might also check to be certain students are listening before attempting to clear up the communication. The truth is that one clear direction or explanation is more effective than several repeated but confusing ones, especially when students are not paying attention. 

Reduce the rules, increase the commitments. We might be tempted to create a long list of rules to cover any behavior and situation we can imagine. However, once the rules are created, we need to ensure that they are followed. We need to teach each rule, monitor behavior to ensure compliance, and manage consequences for violations. Rather than creating a difficult-to-manage system, we might engage students in a discussion of what is necessary to create and maintain a learning-supportive environment and then focus on identifying commitments for everyone to follow. For example, simple commitments like respect yourself, respect others, and respect learning can cover a wide range of situations and position students and us to focus on why behaviors are not acceptable rather than defaulting to a long list of rules. 

Cut cognitive clutter. We want the learning environment to be attractive and stimulating. We also want students to have plenty of materials and resources to support their learning. However, this goal can be compromised by too much of a good thing. Excessive posters, pictures, diagrams, and other wall decorations can become distracting for students. Similarly, too many slides and handouts for every activity can create competition for students’ attention. Before posting and providing support visuals and other resources, we might ask ourselves whether they are worthy supports for learning or just additional decorations. The more we reduce cognitive clutter, the better students can focus on what matters most.   

Focus feedback on the essentials. We can be tempted to make every correction on students’ work and unload all our ideas about how they can improve. We might think that we need to share everything we know to make their performance perfect. Yet students rarely make positive changes in their work when presented with long lists of corrections. Rather than trying to include everything in our feedback, we might reinforce one or two important strengths or areas of progress and focus on one or two things that would make the greatest positive difference. If we are concerned that someone reviewing our feedback might conclude that we fail to see other areas in need of improvement, we might note in our written feedback or as a side comment that we are confining our feedback to essential elements to provide focused support rather than comprehensive corrections.  

A final thought: Our goal is not to oversimplify complex concepts and ideas. Rather, we need to remove unnecessary complications while preserving essential complexities. We want students to wrestle with difficult content and concepts, but not become bogged down with unnecessary confusion, distraction, and redundancy. 

Share Your Tips & Stories

Share your story and the tips you have for getting through this challenging time. It can remind a fellow school leader of something they forgot, or your example can make a difficult task much easier and allow them to get more done in less time. We may publish your comments.
Send Us An Email
Five Emotions that Drive Meaningful Learning

Five Emotions that Drive Meaningful Learning

We might not always think of learning as being an emotionally driven process, but when we attempt to divorce emotions from learning, we diminish the process and lessen its value. Learning is not just a matter of memorization and repetition, although these processes can help students to retain what they learn. When learning is pursued without emotion and purpose, what is gained is soon lost, and what should be valued too often is abandoned in favor of what comes next. 

Unfortunately, many emotions associated with learning are not always comfortable or pleasant, yet their presence can make learning meaningful, rewarding, and empowering. When learning is accompanied by strong emotions, what is learned is more likely to be embedded in memory, recalled with greater ease, and applied with greater understanding and insight.  

Obviously, students can experience many emotions as they tread the path of learning. However, five emotions appear to play especially significant roles. Let’s explore these five emotions and their roles in the learning process.  

Curiosity. The best and most lasting learning begins with an unanswered question, an interesting possibility, or an unexplained phenomenon. Curiosity opens the mind and directs attention, two key conditions for inviting and supporting learning. Learning that responds to curiosity feels voluntary rather than imposed. Curiosity stimulates our brains to release dopamine (the pleasure chemical) and helps to increase focus and prepare for memory building.  

Teachers can create and leverage curiosity for learning by: 

  • Asking questions that students find compelling and relevant. 

  • Designing activities that build interest without giving answers. 

  • Providing partial information that invites further investigation. 

  • Telling an intriguing story with a surprising ending—or no ending at all.  

  • Demonstrating a phenomenon or sharing an experience that invites additional discovery and explanation.  

Confusion. Confusion signals that more organization, understanding, or information is needed. It's the brain’s way of telling us that what we know is not enough or is not organized in a manner to give us the answers we seek. Confusion is not failure. In fact, it is an important step toward understanding. Students often need this reminder and some coaching to maintain learning momentum.  

Teachers can support students through times of confusion by: 

  • Preparing them for it, normalizing it, and reassuring them that their confusion is evidence of learning progress. 

  • Coaching them to describe and explain what they find confusing. Often, students find their way through confusion when they put their experiences into words.  

  • Promoting and supporting productive struggle as a key strategy for learning difficult things.  

  • Helping them determine whether they are confused and need clarity and sensemaking or if they are overwhelmed. When students are overwhelmed, we may need to help them break down tasks and sequence steps.  

Frustration. Frustration is a signal that new learning is stretching current competence. It is evidence that focus and effort are required to overcome a challenge, and it can also be a message that it is time to identify and apply another strategy. Frustration is often the final step before learning breakthroughs.  

Teachers can help students to understand and persist through frustration by: 

  • Reassuring them that when they feel stuck, they are on the threshold of a learning breakthrough.  

  • Reminding them that learning is supposed to be hard.  

  • Helping them break learning tasks into smaller chunks and identify progress markers. 

  • Providing hints and resources rather than answers. 

Hope. Hope sustains motivation and encourages persistence. However, hope is most impactful for learning when students ground their hope in their ability to succeed through their efforts, not their talents. Hope reinforces students’ confidence that if they keep trying, they will improve and eventually succeed. Hope is not a measure of capability; it is evidence of confidence, and confidence that success is possible drives persistence.  

Teachers can nurture and reinforce hope by: 

  • Designing, reinforcing, and celebrating early wins, 

  • Creating progress markers to show growth. 

  • Using the language of “not yet” to remind students that success is possible. 

  • Having students recall times in the past when they struggled and eventually succeeded.  

  • Sharing our confidence in our students’ ability to face and overcome adversity. 

Pride. Pride that is earned through effort and persistence can provide a major boost to confidence in future learning. However, students need to see the connection between their actions and successful outcomes. When success results from controllable factors, students begin to see themselves as learners capable of mastering difficult tasks. Learning success can also foster intrinsic motivation and encourage risk-taking related to learning. 

Teachers can help students build and experience earned pride by: 

  • Encouraging students to reflect on the steps they took and the strategies they used to be successful.  

  • Reinforcing with students that their learning resulted from controllable factors.  

  • Marking and celebrating important progress and success events to reinforce the significance of what students have accomplished. 

  • Having students share what they have learned with or teach other students.  

  • Using language with students that reinforces their identity as a skilled learner.  

Without question, emotions play a crucial role in learning, especially when it is hard. By recognizing, reinforcing, and leveraging emotions as part of learning, we can help students to normalize struggle and frustration, maintain hope, and take pride in what they accomplish. Are there other emotions that you might add to this list as instrumental in designing successful learning experiences? 

When Our Expertise Becomes a Liability

When Our Expertise Becomes a Liability

Expertise is not easy to build. It requires years of study, extensive practice, and sustained focus. Expertise in a content area is built on deep understanding, well-established knowledge constructs, and well-honed schema to address complex problems. Without question, this type of expertise is a great asset.

However, content expertise can also create challenges in our work with students. In fact, in some circumstances, expertise can be a liability. The depth and complexity of what we know can make it difficult to grasp where students are early in their learning journey. We can forget what it was like to be a novice learner.

We must sometimes look beyond our expertise to see what students need and discern how best to meet their needs. Information that seems obvious to us can be anything but obvious to new learners. We can make assumptions that overlook important information and procedural components for early learning. We can underestimate the time, effort, and support students will require. Let’s examine six times when our expertise ceases to be an asset and instead becomes a liability.

Expertise can reduce flexibility. Students come with varied levels of background knowledge and readiness to learn. They often require varied learning experiences and pacing to succeed. However, the process of honing a skill can lead to overreliance on a single method—a method that has worked for the teacher. High levels of competence can lead to overdependence on a strategy or practice that has seemed to work well in the past.  

Antidote: Consider what students need before choosing a strategy or approach.  

Expertise can result in high expectations without support. Years of experience and gained expertise can lead to assumptions about how easily a skill or concept can be learned. Consequently, important scaffolding elements can be overlooked, leaving students struggling to understand key steps and gain insights crucial to learning success. 

Antidote: Listen carefully to students’ questions, identify recurring areas of struggle, and offer scaffolding where needed.  

Expertise can create instructional blind spots. Expertise is a result of extensive practice that leads to automated skills. High levels of expertise can lead to ignoring key initial learning elements, overlooking misconceptions learners hold, and presenting information in “chunks” too large for students to digest.  

Antidote: Adopt a beginner’s mindset. Imagine having no knowledge or experience when planning steps and sequences to build learning paths.  

Expertise can generate overconfidence. With expertise comes a deserved level of confidence. However, too much confidence can inhibit reflection, create resistance to feedback, and result in reluctance to innovate. Certainty can be both a gift and a curse.  

Antidote: Balance (deserved) confidence with humility.  

Expertise can underestimate emotional barriers. Student experiences play significant roles in their learning. Past trauma, current worries, and anxieties about the future can all affect what students learn and how well they learn it. Cultural context and personal perceptions matter. The best instructional strategies and deepest content knowledge may not overcome the barriers that students’ emotions can pose to their learning.   

Antidote: Be open, sensitive, and considerate of the emotions students may be experiencing when designing and facilitating learning activities.  

Expertise can unintentionally create cognitive overload. Experts tend to think in large informational and conceptual chunks. They understand relationships and sequences. However, students often experience new learning content as disconnected elements. Their working memory can quickly and easily be overwhelmed. When working memory is overloaded, little learning occurs, and even less is remembered. 

Antidote: Break information and processes into small elements, provide schema and graphic representations, and ensure adequate time for reflection and application of new learning. 

Content expertise can be a great gift to our teaching. It can also get in the way if we come to rely too heavily on what we know over what students need. The challenge is to embrace our expertise while remembering what it felt like to be a novice learner. When we inject humility, empathy, and curiosity into our teaching and relationships with students, we both become more successful.

Six Strategies to Inspire the Next Generation of Teachers

Six Strategies to Inspire the Next Generation of Teachers

Few schools across the nation have all the teachers they need and can be confident that they will have a wealth of quality candidates for future openings. Too few of today’s young people are choosing teaching as a career to fill current and future needs, which means that we need to do all that we can to make teaching and other education roles attractive and rewarding. Despite their importance, these steps will fall short if young people are not exposed to and supported to choose teaching as a career.  

Research points to the reality that tomorrow’s teachers are sitting in our classrooms today. Most teachers in most schools grew up near where they began their teaching careers. It follows that if we can interest and support students with high potential and an inclination toward teaching to explore what it means to teach, we are more likely to have the quality, number, and variety of teaching candidates we need and seek. However, we must do more than occasionally encourage students to think about teaching. An intentional, comprehensive, and varied approach is required—that's where Career and Technical Education (CTE) programs can be so immensely valuable. Here are six strategies to consider and build on.  

Offer a paraeducator certification program.  

A structured program that leads to paraeducator/paraprofessional certification can give students a strong foundation in various aspects of learning and working with learners. Mini courses on topics such as child development, effective classroom practices, and the science of learning can provide a solid foundation for students to serve as paraeducators while also helping them see themselves as future teachers. Observing and assisting in classrooms can also give students an intimate experience of teaching as both a role and a career. Experience as paraeducators also positions students to observe teaching from a perspective other than as a student. Further, a structured program can expose students to the thinking and decision-making processes of professional teachers.  

Provide paid internships and apprenticeships.  

Roles such as classroom aides, summer teaching assistants, and after-school tutors can offer authentic opportunities for students to “try on” teaching roles. Having the experiences paid for also adds value and responsibility to them. Internships and apprenticeships can also expose students to a wide range of challenges and experiences that reflect what it means to be a teacher.   

Create opportunities for students to engage in micro- and peer-teaching.  

Some less-intensive options for students to experience what it means to teach can be attractive to students who are curious about teaching and want to try it out but either do not have time for or are not yet ready for more intensive experiences. Micro- and peer-teaching also entail lower investment and risk for students who are curious but unsure of their interests.   

Offer dual credit courses to give students a college head start.  

Courses that offer high school and college credit can be a great option for students who are certain that teaching is in their future. Not only are students exposed to more advanced content and skills, but credits earned prior to college enrollment can reduce tuition costs and build momentum for students’ preparation for a career in teaching.  

Offer mentorships with strong, supportive, and inspiring teachers.  

Having opportunities to engage with and learn from someone who is passionate about and an expert in their work can help students gain a positive, realistic view of what it means to teach. Mentors can also advise students on areas of experience and learning that will help them to be better prepared for teaching as a profession.  

Sponsor a future teacher club.  

Clubs for students interested in teaching were once common in schools. However, their popularity has waned over the past few decades. Nevertheless, an organization designed around student interests, with opportunities for student leadership and experiences that students find appealing, can support students considering a career in teaching. Students might engage in activities such as lesson design, visiting and observing classes, hosting teacher panels, and conducting interviews. Participation in a future teacher club can also give students a sense of identity and stimulate pride in their career interest.  

The truth is that tomorrow’s teachers are sitting in today’s classrooms waiting to be noticed, nurtured, and prepared. When they have meaningful opportunities to experience teaching, learn from skilled mentors, and see the impact they can have on others, something magical happens: Teaching shifts from something they observe to a future they can imagine.

Beyond Hand Raising: Smarter Ways to Ask Questions

Beyond Hand Raising: Smarter Ways to Ask Questions

We employ questions throughout lessons to gain feedback on our instruction, surface areas of confusion and misconception, and to support classroom management. Having students respond to questions is a useful strategy for understanding what background knowledge they bring and what they are learning in real time. Questions can also be used to ensure that students are paying attention.  

Of course, we want our questions to be well-framed, meaningful, and revealing of what students are absorbing and can explain. However, how we pose questions also has implications for the information we gain and the psychological comfort students experience. For example, when students are wondering whether they are about to be called upon, they may pay more attention. When students have time to reflect and prepare answers, they are more likely to respond with information that better reflects their thinking and learning.  

Obviously, there are many ways to manage the process of asking questions. Each approach can serve a purpose and has advantages and disadvantages. And each varies in the amount of preparation allowed to students, the predictability with which questions are presented, and the amount of emotional safety students experience.  

The three most common questioning strategies are cold calling, warm calling, and signal calling. Let’s examine these three popular strategies, what they offer, and the drawbacks they can present.  

Cold calling involves asking students questions without a specific, individual warning that they may be called upon. Teachers may pause a lesson to ask questions or set aside time after a lesson or activity for students to respond. The purpose of this approach is to keep students cognitively engaged in anticipation of being asked a question. It also allows for random checking of understanding and prevents a few students from dominating participation. Cold calling can also be used to hold students accountable and gain the attention of students who appear not to be paying attention. While this approach offers opportunities for feedback and management, it can negatively affect students' emotional safety, especially those who need time to reflect and prepare before sharing their thinking. It can also be a source of anxiety and embarrassment that pushes against authentic engagement and “full-bodied” learning.  

Strategies to make cold calling effective: 

  • Ensure a warm and respectful tone in questioning and follow-up. 

  • Respond with interest and curiosity to incorrect responses. 

  • Offer supportive prompts to nudge and expand responses in a productive direction. 

  • Treat mistakes as a natural part of learning and a step toward understanding. 

  • Avoid overuse of cold calls to maintain attention and manage other behaviors.   

Warm calling is a softer, more supportive approach to questioning. Typically, students are given time and activities to help them prepare to answer questions. As examples, students may take a minute to make notes or consult with classmates before being expected to respond. This approach shares accountability with cold calling, but involves less risk-taking, lower threat, fewer non-responses, and increased student confidence. For many students, this approach leads to deeper and more complete responses. It can also support shy, less confident, and struggling students to feel more successful. Further, the additional thinking time and rehearsal increase retention of new learning.  

Strategies to make warm calling effective: 

  • Allocate adequate, but not excessive, time for reflection and preparation. 

  • Pose questions that are more complex and require more reflective and analytical thinking than might be presented when cold calling.  

  • Offer response preparation strategies that maintain individual accountability while also mining memories and stimulating deep thinking.  

  • Press for more complete responses than might be acceptable when cold calling. 

  • Monitor to ensure that a small group of students does not dominate preparation activities and response opportunities.  

Signal calling, as the name implies, involves visible indicators to assess and assign question response activities. Signaling might be used to indicate who is confident and ready to respond, or who is uncertain or needs more time. This approach also provides real-time feedback on how well students are tracking with the lesson. Signal calling features accountability, but in this context, students share information about their learning and readiness during the activity. A variety of signaling techniques can be employed. Students might use hand signals such as thumbs up/thumbs down/thumbs sideways or “fist-to-five” confidence ratings to signal their readiness. They might use colored cards, whiteboards, or other strategies. Information students provide can guide choices about which students might be selected to respond. 

Strategies to make signal calling effective: 

  • Keep signal choices simple and clear to avoid confusion. 

  • Explore student signals that reflect uncertainty or confusion to determine causes. 

  • Balance response distribution to avoid having only confident students respond. 

  • Monitor signals to ensure that students are not “hiding” or following peer responses to avoid thinking independently. 

  • Combine signal-calling with follow-up questions to examine the depth of understanding and readiness to move forward.  

The three questioning strategies discussed all present advantages and disadvantages depending on the type of learning involved and our purpose in presenting questions. In general, signal calling works best to gauge student readiness. Warm calling supports deeper participation. Cold calling can maintain engagement and accountability. The key is to match the strategy we choose with the purpose of our instruction and the learning-related information we need.